Mozart Effect
Although it is only in recent times that
scientists have started to document the
effects of music, the qualities of
music were understood even in earliest times.
Evidence suggests that
dance and song preceded speech, which means that music is
the original
language of humans. Researcher's have found that about two-thirds
of the
inner ear's cilia resonate only at the higher frequencies that are
commonly
found in music (3,000 - 20,000 Hz). This seems to indicate that
primitive
humans communicated primarily through song or tone. The ancient
Greek
philosopher Pythagoras, best known for his work in mathematics, thought
the
whole universe was comprised of sounds and numbers. There has long been
an
awareness that music affects us, even if the reasons are not clear. Around
900
B.C., David played the harp "to cure Saul's derangement"
(Gonzalez-Crussi).
One os the world's oldest medical documents, the Ebers
Papyrus (circa 1500
B.C.), prescribed incantations that Egyptian
physicians chanted to heal the
sick. This is perhaps the first recorded use
of music for therapy. The positive
influence of music may have also saved
Beethoven's life in the early eighteenth
century. In a letter he wrote, "I
would have ended my life-it was only my
art that held me back" (Kamien).
Every human civilization has developed
some sort of musical idiom and has
used it as a form of tranquilizer, as a
lullaby. Great civilizations have
developed without the wheel, without a written
language, without money, but
the use of soothing sounds seems to be a very basic
component of human
physiology. There are distinct differences between
compositions of different
societies, but in spite of this, they can convey the
same moods, the same
feelings, in all people. As Louis Pasteur's Germ Theory of
Illness
launched the era of scientific medicine, music largely faded from
formal
medical settings. Fortunately, it never completely disappeared.
American
medicine first started experimenting with the therapeutic use of
music during
the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. As early as 1804,
Edwin Atlee,
wrote an essay in which he hoped to show that music, "has a
powerful
influence upon the mind, and consequently on the body." Modern
music
therapy began to develop in the 1940's when psychotherapists used music
to calm
anxious patients, and music therapy programs were established in
several
university psychology departments. The relatively new field of
neuro-musicology
has been developed to experiment with music as a tool and to
dissect and shape
it to the needs of society. The auditory sense The visible
portion of the ear
consists of an external shell, with an aperture known as
the meatus or auditory
canal in the lower half. At the other end of this
canal, about an inch inside
the head is a small membrane of skin about 3/1000
of an inch thick. This piece
of skin is stretched tightly over a framework of
bone much like skin is
stretched over a frame of wood to make a drum, and
hence the name eardrum. Just
behind the eardrum lies a chain of three small
bones known as ossicles. The
first ossicle is in contact with the eardrum,
and the last presses against the
oval window that leads to the cochlea. The
ossicles serve to amplify the tiny
changes in air pressure. The oval window
passes the motion on to the fluid
inside the cochlea. The neural tissue in
the cochlea lies on the basilar
membrane. The basilar membrane holds the
auditory receptors, tiny hair cells
called cilia. Waves in the fluid of the
ear stimulate the hair cells to send
signals to through the thalamus to the
temporal lobes of the brain. Sound
reaches the ear in the form of waves which
have traveled through the surrounding
air. When the waves reach the ear, they
exert varying pressures on the ear-drum
and it is sent into motion. This
motion is eventually detected by nerves and
sent to the brain (as described
above). The ear-drum is a remarkably sensitive
instrument, an air
displacement of only a ten-billionth of an inch is enough to
send a signal to
the brain. This is far more sensitive than the best barometers
that
scientists have today. Although the ear is very sensitive to minute
changes
in air pressure, it is only when these pressure changes are repeated
in rapid
succession that the messages are passed to the brain. Music Therapy
Heart
Attacks The latest research demonstrates that music therapy has a
variety of
healing effects. A study was conducted on three separate coronary
care units in
hospitals. One group received only standard care, the second
group practiced a
form of meditation, and the third group listened to
sedative classical and
popular music. The patients who received only the
standard care all showed high
levels of stress hormones in their blood, and
rapid heart rates. These are both
undesirable reactions that can impair the
immune system and slow healing. The
meditation and music groups showed
significantly lower heart rates and levels of
stress hormones. The music
group was the least stressed. Cancer In a study at
the Montefiore Hospital in
Pittsburgh, fifteen adults suffering from a variety
of cancers were receiving
chemotherapy. Common side effects of chemotherapy
include nausea and
vomiting. A music-imagery program significantly reduced the
nausea and the
amount of vomiting. Immune system Stress triggers the release of
certain
hormones that suppress the immune system. In one study of night-shift
nurses
who suffered from health problems, a twenty-minutes tape of sedative
music
and guided imagery reduced their levels of stress hormones.
Blood
Pressure/Heart Rate A study at the State University of New York
suggests that
music could help prevent the rise in blood pressure that some
people experience
while performing potentially stressful tasks. The study
tested the effects of
music on 50 male surgeons as they performed mental
arithmetic tasks. The
surgeons performed this task under three conditions:
while listening to music of
their own choice, listening to Pachelbel's "Canon
in D", and in
silence. Blood pressures increased the least when the surgeons
were listening to
music of their own choice. Blood pressure rose when the
surgeons performed the
task while listening to Pachelbel, and increased the
most in complete silence.
The average heart rate followed a pattern
similar to the blood pressure. Speed
and accuracy was the best while
listening to Pachelbel. The type of music that
the surgeons selected for
themselves did not seem to affect their outcomes.
Forty-six of the
participants selected classical music, two selected jazz, and
two selected
Irish folk. This study gives strong evidence that a soothing
environment can
help reduce blood-pressure elevations that result from
psychological stress.
The entrainment effect offers one other explanation for
the physiological
effects of music. Entrainment is the bodies ability to
synchronize its
rhythms with the rhythms of vibrating bodies around it. For
example, babies
in neonatal care units have been known to synchronize their
natural rhythms
with those generated by nearby computer monitors, matching their
heart rate
to the monitor's beeping. Studies on adults have also been able to
duplicate
this effect with music. When volunteers were subjected to stress,
their heart
rates rose as expected. However, when they listened to a simulated
slow heart
beat, their tension levels decreased and their heart rates slowed. It
is
possible to change a person's heart rate with music that is written in
a
specific tempo. When patients with a racing heart listen to music with
about 50
to 60 beats per minute, their heart rate usually slows down to
synchronize with
the slower rhythm of the music. Autism Nonverbal
communication between and
autistic child playing the drums and a therapist on
the piano can serve to bring
a child out of isolation, the Journal of the
American Medical Association
reported. Clive E. Robbins, Ph.D., says "it's a
way of reaching into the
child's mind." He compared the musical interaction
to verbal communication.
"As we speak, we improvise, you ask a question, I
respond. So it is with
music. It can be used as flexibly as we use speech to
reach children with
language problems. It bypasses those difficulties.
Neurologic research is
discovering that the brain comes into synthetic
activity in response to music.
Some say the brain is fundamentally
programmed so that the organic connections
are symphonic rather than
mechanistic." Exercise Light rock music is often
used in various exercise
programs. It helps the body to move to an even rhythm,
and the muscles to
work more smoothly. It also has the effect of increasing
stamina, boosting
endurance and lowering heart rate. Memory The right hemisphere
of the brain,
which has to do with feelings, imagery, and the unconscious, is
activated by
music. Janalea Hoffman, a therapists works with a lot of adults who
have
experienced major gaps in their memories of childhood. Using music, they
are
often able to recall lost or suppressed experiences, which in turn
may
eliminate the emotional underpinning for their physical ailments. Paul
Newham,
founder of the International Association for Voice and Movement
Therapy in
London, explored the therapeutic difference between speaking
and singing.
Whereas Sigmund Freud pioneered the talking cure, in which
patients free
associations offered a "royal road" to the unconscious mind,
Newham
believes that the singing voice offers a more direct route to the
unconscious
mind. He says, "the whole purpose of psychoanalysis is to disable
the
controlling domination of the conscious, particularly the superego, to
see what
emerges when the language of the unconscious is allowed to speak.
Freud did that
through language, through free association. I think that it's
one stage further
to strip away verbility itself and to allow the voice to
speak directly through
song." States of Consciousness It has been repeatedly
demonstrated that
brain waves can be modified by both music and
self-generated sounds. Ordinary
consciousness consists of beta waves, which
vibrate from 14 to 20 Hz. Beta waves
occur when we focus on daily activities
in teh external world, as well as when
we experience negative emotions.
Heightened awareness and calm are characterized
by alpha waves, which cycle
from 8 to 13 Hz. Periods of peak creativity,
meditation, and sleep are
characterized by theta waves, from 4 to 7 Hz. Deep
sleep, and deep meditation
and unconsciousness produce delta waves that range
from .5 to 3 Hz. The
slower the brain waves, the more relaxed, contended, and
peaceful a person
feels. Music with about 60 beats per minute can shift
conscouisness from the
beta toward the alpha range, enhancing alertness and
well-being. While most
people respond physically and emotionally to music, a few
go beyond that. For
some music therapy is mystical experience used to transport
them into altered
states of consciousness. Patients sometimes report
transpersonal experiences
with music, and the impression it leaves may linger
for months or even years.
These experiences can have a therapeutic effect by
changing the individual at
a deep spiritual level. Effects of various types of
music Gregorian Chant -
creates a sense of relaxed spaciousness, reduces stress,
deepens breathing
Baroque - invokes sense of stability, order, and safety and
creates a
mentally stimulating environment, increases rate of learning and
memory
retention Classical - can improve memory, concentration, and
spatial
perception Romantic - enhances sympathy, love, and compassion,
invokes theme of
individualism or mysticism Impressionist - evokes dreamlike
images, can unlock
creative impulses Jazz and Blues - helps to release deep
joy and sadness Big
Band - inspires light movement, creates sense of
well-being Rock - stimulates
active movement, may increase tension and stress
New Age - increases sense of
space and time, induces state of relaxed
alertness Heavy metal - stimulates the
nervous system. It is typically an
outward exhibition of inner turmoil Country -
has been known to increases
suicidal tendencies The Mozart Effect Alfred Tomatis,
M.D., a French
physician has spent five decades studying the healing and
creative effects of
music, particularly that of Mozart. He has tested over
100,000 clients in
listening centers all over the world. Lately, researchers
have learned that
the music of one composer in particular rises above all other
types in its
ability to heal, namely that of Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. The unique
ability
of this music to heal the body, and strengthen the mind is known as
the
Mozart Effect. One of Tomatis' patients included the well-known
French actor
Gerard Depardieu. Early in his career, the man struggled to
become an actor.
Depardieu could not express himself, the more he tried,
the worse his stammering
became. Tomatis traced the cause of Depardieu's
voice and memory problems to
deeper emotional problems. Depardieu's treatment
consisted of listening to
Mozart two hours a day for several months. Soon
his appetite improved, he slept
better, and eventually he began to speak more
clearly. He went on to become a
popular actor known for his mellifluous
voice. Tomatis consistently found that
regardless of a listener's tastes or
previous exposure to the composer, the
music of Mozart calmed listeners,
improved spatial perception, and allowed them
to express themselves more
clearly. He found that Mozart achieved the best
long-term results. In 1993,
Frances H. Rauscher, Ph.D., demonstrated that ten
minutes of listening to
Mozart can temporarily increase intelligence. He had
thirty-six students
stake a standard intelligence test after listening to either
silence, a
relaxing guided imagery tape, or Mozart. After the period of silence,
the
average student score was 110. After the guided imagery tape, the
average
score was 111. After listening to Mozart the score significantly
increased to
119. Even people who said they did not like the music had
higher scores.
Rauscher says that, "listening to complex, nonrepetitive
music like Mozart
may stimulate neural pathways that are important in
thinking" (Castleman).
Rauscher used the same experimental design to test
other types of music. In a
later study, Rauscher was able to duplicate the
effect of Mozart's music. He
also tested compositions by Philip Glass and
other highly rhythmic dance pieces.
No increase in students IQ was
observed after listening to this type of music.
This seems to suggest
that hypnotic musical structures will not enhance mental
abilities. In a
different study, scientists explored the neurophysiological
bases of this
enhancement. Spatial intelligence was tested by projecting sixteen
abstract
figures similar to folded piece of paper on an overhead screen for
one
minute. The exercises tested whether seventy-nine could tell what the
shapes
would look like when they were unfolded. Over a five-day period, one
group
listened to Mozart, another to silence, and third to mixed sounds. The
studies
showed that all the groups improved their scores from day one to day
two, but
the Mozart group's score rose 62% percent, compared to 14% for the
silent group,
and 11% for the mixed-sound group. The Mozart group continued
to achieve the
highest scores on subsequent days. Rauscher also conducted a
study that showed
that music lessons or listening to music can enhance
spatial reasoning
performance. The spatial reasoning of 19 preschool children
who received eight
months of music lessons far exceeded the spatial reasoning
performance of 15
preschoolers who did not receive music lessons. A variety
of other people have
been discovering the benefits of Mozart's music. For
example, in monasteries in
Britain, monks play music to the animals in
their care, and have found that cows
serenaded with Mozart give more milk. In
Washington State, Department of
Immigration and Naturalization officials
play Mozart and Baroque music during
English classes for new arrivals and
reports that it speeds up their learning.
The city of Edmonton in
Alberta, Canada plays Mozart's string quartets into the
city squares to calm
pedestrian traffic. Officials have found, in addition to
other benefits, drug
dealings have decreased. Many theories have been proposed
to explain the
Mozart Effect. According to Gordon Shaw, a theoretical
physicist,
Mozart's music may give the brain a warm up. He suspects that
complex music
facilitates certain complex neuronal patterns involved in high
brain activities
like math and chess. According to David Sobel, M.D., "At
least part of the
thrill of music seems to come from the release of
endorphines, the powerful
opiate-like chemicals produced in the brain that
induce euphoria and relieve
pain. Administering drugs that block endorphin
production significantly blunts
the joy of music" (Castleman). Sedative music
reduces the levels of stress
hormones, such as adrenaline, and has a calming
effect on the limbic system of
the brain, which plays a key role in emotion.
Using special instruments, Tomatis
discovered that burnout, fatigue, and the
debilitating effects of stress come
when the central gray nuclei cells of the
brain run low on electrical potential.
These cells act like small
batteries, they generate the electricity for brain
waves that can be detected
on EEGs. Before and after brain maps made from EEGs,
show that the brain is
stimulated by high frequency sound. Interestingly, these
cells are not
recharged by body metabolism. These cells are charged up by
something outside
the body, namely sound. In particular, high frequency sounds
from 5,000 -
8,000 Hz. Interestingly, before babies are born, they hear their
mother's
voice at frequencies of about 8,000 Hz as a result of the distortion
when
sound travels through fluid. After checking the music of many
different
composers, Tomatis found that the music of Mozart was richest in
these higher
frequencies. In Cymatics, Hans Jenny, a Swiss engineer and
doctor, describes the
science of how sound and vibration interact with
matter. Jenny shows that
intricate geometric figures can be formed by sound.
He has produced oscillating
figures in liquids and gases. The forms and
shapes that can be created by sound
are infinite and can be varied simply by
changing the pitch, the harmonics of
the tone, and the material that is
vibrating. Sounds, especially music, can have
a similar effect on cells,
tissues and organs. "Vibrating sounds form
patterns and create energy fields
of resonance and movement in the surrounding
space. We absorb these energies,
and they subtly alter our breath, blood
pressure, muscle tension, skin
temperature, and other internal rhythms"
(Campbell). Through this type of
research, scientists and physicians have become
aware that the vibrations
transmitted by music can have positive effects on
patients (or negative
effects if the wrong type of music is used). A great deal
of music has a
rhythm analogous to the average human heart beat (70-80 beats per
minute). We
know the rhythms of music affect the rhythms of the autonomic
nervous system,
which regulates a vast a array of systems in our body.
Therefore, we can
understand the physiological and psychological importance
of
music.
Bibliography
Campbell, Don. The Mozart Effect. New
York: Avon Books, 1997. Campbell, Don.
"The riddle of the Mozart Effect."
Natural Health January-February
1998: 114. (Reprinted by Information
Access Company) Castleman, Michael and
Spangler, Tina. "The Healing Power
of Music." Natural Health
September-October 1994: 68. Gonzalez-Crussi,
Frank. "Hearing
Pleasures." Health March 1989: 65. Hoffman Janalea.
"Tuning in to the
power of music." RN June 1997: 52. (Reprinted by
Information Access
Company) Jeans, James. Science and Music. New York:
Dover Publications, 1968.
Kamien, Roger. Music: An Appreciation. New
York: McGraw, 1994. Long, Synthia.
"Doctors Find Music Works Well With
Sedatives and Anesthetics."
Medicine 23 December 1996: 41. Marwick,
Charles. "Leaving concert hall for
clinic, therapists now test music's
¦charms' (Medical News and
Perspectives)." JAMA, The Journal of the
American Medical Association 24
January 1996: 267. (reprinted by
Information Access Company) Ostrander, Sheila
and Schroeder, Lynn.
Superlearning 2000. New York: Dell Publishing, 1994. Pert,
Candace B.
Molecules of Emotion. New York: Scribner, 1997. Ramo, Joshua Cooper.
"Music
Soothes the Savage Brain: Listening to Mozart Improves Intelligence
Test
Scores." Newsweek 25 October 1993: 51. Rosenfeld, Anne H. "Music,
the
Beautiful Disturber." Psychology Today December 1985: 48. Uretsky,
Samuel
D. "Music Therapy." Independent Living Provider
January-February 1996:
32. ( reprinted by Information Access Company) Weiten,
Wayne. Psychology
Themes and Variations. Pacific Grove, CA:Brooks/Cole, 1997.
Whitmore,
Barbara. "Musical Birth: sound strategies for relaxation."
Mothering Fall
1997: 56. (Reprinted by Information Access Company)